The Struggle to Pass a Federal Data Privacy Bill

A Deep Dive into the American Privacy Rights Act

On Thursday morning, June 27th, the U.S. House Energy and Commerce Committee abruptly cancelled its markup of the American Privacy Rights Act (APRA). In a dramatic turn of events, the House Republican leadership and Energy and Commerce Committee Chair Cathy McMorris Rodgers (R-Wash.) found themselves locked in an unusual and intense confrontation over the pivotal data privacy bill. The APRA bill has sparked significant debate and division within the party, just as it was set to head for a crucial committee markup.

The Unfolding Drama

The stakes are high for Chairwoman Rodgers, who views the APRA as a cornerstone of her legislative legacy in her final year in Congress. The bill represents a bipartisan effort, crafted in collaboration with Rep. Frank Pallone (D-N.J.), and aims to establish new federal privacy standards. Despite its significance, the bill faces substantial resistance, not only from within the committee but also from the higher echelons of the Republican leadership.

On the eve of the committee markup, Speaker Mike Johnson and House Majority Leader Steve Scalise convened a call with the Energy and Commerce Republicans, excluding Rodgers. This unprecedented move highlights the growing tension and underscores the leadership’s concerns about the bill’s viability. Scalise, in particular, has been vocal about his reservations, citing strong opposition from business groups and tech companies, which are critical of the proposed regulations.

Core Issues and Divergent Views

At the heart of the controversy are several key elements of the APRA. The bill seeks to impose stringent requirements on how tech companies collect, use, and retain consumer data. It also aims to enhance consumer control over their personal information and includes a private right of action, enabling individuals to sue companies that misuse their data without consent.

While privacy advocates and some conservatives back the proposal, GOP leaders remain skeptical. Scalise has expressed frustration, stating that his office had offered to collaborate with Rodgers for months, an offer he claims was declined. This ongoing dispute reached a boiling point when GOP leaders urged Rodgers to address unresolved issues in the bill. Defiantly, she announced the markup just hours after these discussions, asserting that it was the appropriate time to advance the legislation.

The Path Forward

Rodgers remains steadfast in her belief that the markup is merely a step in the legislative process and that moving forward on this high-profile issue is imperative. However, the path to passing the APRA is fraught with challenges. The skepticism from Republican leadership, coupled with opposition from influential business sectors, casts doubt on the bill’s future.

The Energy and Commerce Committee is also slated to mark up the Kids Online Safety Act (KOSA), another bipartisan effort focused on protecting children online. The simultaneous consideration of these significant pieces of legislation underscores the committee’s broader commitment to addressing privacy and safety concerns in the digital age.

Conclusion

The battle over the American Privacy Rights Act highlights the complexities and political maneuvering inherent in passing comprehensive data privacy legislation at the federal level. As the committee markup looms, the outcome remains uncertain. Chairwoman Rodgers faces the daunting task of navigating internal party conflicts and external pressures to achieve her legislative goals. The unfolding narrative serves as a testament to the intricate balance of power, influence, and advocacy that shapes the legislative process in Washington, D.C.

Click here to learn more about our Preference and Consent Management Platform! Clarip takes enterprise privacy governance to the next level and helps organizations reduce risks, engage better, and gain customers’ trust! Contact us at www.clarip.com or call Clarip at 1-888-252-5653 for a demo.

Email Now:

Mike Mango, VP of Sales
mmango@clarip.com